Search Hardwicke Barristers for:

Did you see . . .? Recent property cases you may have missed

20.12.2011

Potter v Dyer – 30.11.11 – CA – [2011] EWCA 1417
Misrepresentation – Affirmation – Joint tenancies – Notice to quit by one tenant.
Held: A’s case involving an argument that he could partially affirm a contract but remain entitled to rescind the remainder was unsupported by authority. The notion of partial affirmation was rejected.

K/S Victoria Street v House of Fraser – 1.12.11 – ChD – [2011] EWHC 3179
House of Fraser's attempt to skin a cat another way fails. Permission to appeal refused re their attempts to amend in order to advance their previously unsuccessful case on the basis of estoppel by convention.

Islington LBC v Boyle – 6.12.11 - CA – [2011] EWCA Civ 1450
Secure tenancy – Possession - Residence requirement – tenant not living at property for four years.
Held: A finding that the tenant still in occupation of the premises despite her four year absence was insufficient. The residence requirement for a secure tenancy was that the tenant occupy the premises as her only or principal home. The Judge had failed to consider whether it was her only or principal home. Case remitted.

Banks v Morgan– 15.12.11 - CA – [2011] EWCA Civ 1568
Rights of Way – The use of plans to define the extent of rights – Agreements, orders and finality.
Note: This judgment should be taken a cautionary tale for practitioners. Parties found themselves involved in a multiplicity of proceedings with confused decisions and agreements. Clear plans accompanied by clear defining declarations or terms of agreement are key to properly resolving property disputes for your clients and their successors.

Case summaries prepared by Brie Stevens-Hoare

Back to Case Reports